Well Onondaga, have never heard of anyone hunting deer with a 458, but to each his own, and IF I had one would probably try it as well cuz other than the fact that the rifle is probably heavy as he-double-ll, just figure it is an over grown 45-70 with a belt. You must be deer hunting in the Adarondics, or out of state, unless they changed the laws since I left home (Livingston Co.) 50 years ago when it was all shotgun w/slugs. Did hear that they now allow ML's in New York as well.
1Shirt!